By Liz Lancashire

At the end of last month, (February), Groupon’s chief executive announced his departure. He did it by way of a letter to his employees and colleagues, in it saying that he's OK with having failed.

Groupon was, and arguably still is, the 'go-to' site for consumers to nab amazingly cheap offers, and for retailers to offer sure-fire winning deals to get feet through the doors and bums on seats.

What Groupon does well is to give retailers a one-off high profile hit. It gets them in front of thousands of online readers, and (potentially) gets them a large volume of customers in the shop/salon/restaurant, with (potentially) an increase in orders or bookings (particularly at times that are difficult, or even costly, for the retailer to fulfil).

What Groupon, and other similar sites, don't do, is give the retailer any customer loyalty. The customer is not theirs, it's Groupon's, (irrespective of contract) and the customers will take advantage of the cheap manicure, thank you very much, then check Groupon again the following week for another cheap manicure. Not, (take note), a return visit to same salon, a return visit to Groupon. The customer loyalty lies with Groupon, not the retailer.

The retailer has to offer a massively discounted price (of which Groupon takes 35%), and has to be able to commit to a large number of offers. The model is built on volume of people, the stack it high, sell 'em cheap kind. But critics says this is unsustainable and easily copied, which it is.

Brief analysis of Groupon’s business model over; now back to the letter. Mason admitted in his parting letter that he, that they (Groupon), had overlooked the importance and value of customer data, neglecting to find out what was really important to their customer. The statement is telling, and shows that Mason misunderstood who his customer was. His focus was on the consumer and giving them the best possible, cheapest deal, at the expense of HIS customers, the retailers. The retailers ended up unhappy and out of pocket, steam-rolled into providing loss-making deals. And when suppliers get hacked off and realise they're getting nothing from a deal, they shoot through, leaving an opening in the market for other deal sites to fill, with better rates and consumer intelligence for the retailer. And of course other ways of marketing their business.

This lack of understanding of the importance of data was mirrored in my own experience the other day. I received a sales call at the door from what I thought of as a nice small company, with a solid history and strong ethics. They wanted me to make an immediate purchase. They offered no incentive to buy and the deal was “If you don't like it you don't have to buy again.” – like I said, no incentive. I said I wouldn't make a decision to buy immediately but would happily provide my email address to be kept up to date with the brand. The sales chap didn't want it, and insisted that the business was built on direct sales, (since 1908), and that some of their customers have been with them for 50 or 60 years. He may never call on me again, and to be blunt, those customers of 50 or 60 years won’t be customers forever. History and heritage is all very well, but when it means you lose customers because of fear of change, it's time for a rebirth.

You can’t always provide exactly what your customers want but if you have opportunities right under your nose and don’t take them; like data that can inform the future direction of your business, provide insight in to what the customer wants, and back up your sales spiel; prospects who may well buy from you in the future if you give them an alternative method of buying and a way of staying in touch – you may stand less chance of sighing Sayonara.

 
 
by Liz Lancashire

Being in a club is great.  My first one was the rainbow club, when I was six years old.  My sister, two of our friends, and I, met in the attic every Monday night to do colouring in.  We saved 5p each, every week until we had enough to go and watch Annie at the cinema.  My second club experience was not so great.  I sent off my application form to join the Five Star fan club.  A few weeks later I received a signed photograph from them, then never heard a dickybird from them again.  I think the money might have run out.

These days I'm a member of lots of clubs and loyalty schemes. Tesco's clubcard, Sainsbury's nectar card, the Co-op membership card, Boots advantage points, various fuel cards, Cafe Nero, Body Shop, you name it.  And do I mind them all collecting and using my data?  No I don't, because I'm getting something good in return.

Boots advantage points has been running for since 1997, very successfully, and now Boots' biggest rival, Superdrug, have announced they too are starting their own loyalty scheme.  Superdrug have always differentiated themselves from Boots by positioning themselves as the cheaper option.  But differentiation on price alone is not enough for this retailer any longer and they are clearly looking at ways to target their customers better.  

I have lots of loyalty cards, but does it make me loyal?  Well yes, but loyal to quite a few. (Note I have the Tesco, Co-op and Nectar cards – lots of shopping around for me). The loyalty card a great way of keeping customers on side, but there are other, well tested methods you can try too, such as sending birthday cards, the seasonal gifts, and special deals for long term customers only. Tesco does this very well by giving vouchers and money off vouchers for items you buy regularly, but also introducing you to similar but potentially new items. Boots does it well by its generous points scheme, which they have now extended to what they call the Treat Street, where you can use these points in other shops . Body Shop gives you a free gift in your birthday month, making you feel special and cared for. And the original, Co-op membership card (birthplace Rochdale) gives you a share of the business profits.  Airlines have also done this kind club marketing for years in the form of frequent flyers clubs (nb: I'm not a member of any frequent flyer clubs...yet).

It's not only national retailers that offer or can benefit from loyalty marketing though, and it's not only the loyalty gained that makes this worth doing.  There is also the valuable information you find out about about your customers, i.e., who they are, what type of customers they are, what they like and don't like etc. By asking the questions and monitoring this, you can fine-tune your business to their needs and wants.  Small and independent beauty salons, coffee shops, mechanics, dry cleaners; business like these can all offer simple loyalty schemes, and many of them do.  But the business to business sector can also make use of it.  Consultants can offer incentives or price discounts for ongoing or repeat project work, venues can offer loyalty cards for repeat bookings, suppliers can offer 2 for 1s or cross-sell some of their other products or services.

We believe in the gift of giving, so when we get a new project, we like to say thanks in a way that only Owls can.  But don't get excited, we're not giving away free flights.